My first game I actually want to finish

[LeiterJakab]

I've been planning to start making this game for a while now, but now I actually started working on it. It is a top down stealth action game.
Although I have a lot of poorly documented ideas of where I want to go with it, I'd rather take it where the players would like to go... or something? So I started a blog, to post the things I'm doing, and hopefully get a lot of feedback and constructive criticism. My blog probably isn't going to be very good, but I will keep my posts short and to the point. And maybe I'll even upgrade my English and puntuation a little bit to make it less of a pain to read.
But the point is me writing as little as possible and you giving me lots of good ideas. I basically want to con you into designing a game for me.
http://onetinyleap.wordpress.com/

[Endoperez]

I basically want to con you into designing a game for me.

I'm afraid that won't work. You won't get a design, just ideas. For example:

I want dismemberment and bows and katanas and ranged weapons and foxes. You should make it more like Thief series and more like X-Com and more like Metal Gear Solid. It should also have achievements and when you get levels you should become invisible.

[adwuga]

Maybe you can pause time to think, and place spy cameras, so you can see enemies that your character cant.

For a whole design, I don't like most top down games, except frozen synapse, so I have nothing to offer.

[LeiterJakab]

I basically want to con you into designing a game for me.

I'm afraid that won't work. You won't get a design, just ideas. For example:

I want dismemberment and bows and katanas and ranged weapons and foxes. You should make it more like Thief series and more like X-Com and more like Metal Gear Solid. It should also have achievements and when you get levels you should become invisible.

I should really stop making joking I guess. That kind of input is exactly what I will be looking for.

Maybe you can pause time to think, and place spy cameras, so you can see enemies that your character cant.

For a whole design, I don't like most top down games, except frozen synapse, so I have nothing to offer.

Or this. I liked Frozen Synapse very much too. I have been considering making it turn base. I would like to make it top down for a number of reasons. The camera distance will reduce the need for highly detailed assets and it will help getting a more tactical understanding of your surroundings. Placeable gadgets to help with that is a very good idea.

They way I hope it will work is this, I will post my ideas and the things I'm currently trying to do, and anyone interested can reply if they like it, what they think would make it better.

[Ragdollmaster]

I want dismemberment and bows and katanas and ranged weapons and foxes. You should make it more like... Metal Gear Solid.

Incidentally all of the things you list there are present in MGS.

[LeiterJakab]

Must have been a subconscious thing.

[LeiterJakab]

As promised I posted the first update. I'm still not sure how long these posts should be. I could write in more detail about everything, but I don't want to be too boring since I d like to get feedback. On the other hand I probably won't get much feedback unless I provide details. Such a dilemma.
http://onetinyleap.wordpress.com/

[Endoperez]

Must have been a subconscious thing.

Since I haven't played any MGS games, I doubt it.

[zzwerty]

I think you need to take some advice from Peter Molydeux.
In other words, think about adding some more creative and innovative elements into your game's design. Don't just make a top-down Metal Gear clone.

Perhaps have all the characters be Cats? They're pretty sneaky.

[LeiterJakab]

Well that would be MGS with cats. Unfortunately I only played MGS on the original PS. That's also bad because one of them is rumoured to have very good AI.
What I would like to accomplish is more complex AI. This means more complex noise perception for example, and more detailed processing of such stimuli. But also less mechanic behaviours. Maybe less forgiving too. This also means a non linear gameplay.
I'll write about ideas and goals in future posts though.

[Count Roland]

Metal gear was top down in the first place though, that was the only version I ever bothered playing anyway.

[LeiterJakab]

I heard you like developement updates. I have demo of my steering behaviours I have been working on pretty hard. I'm rather proud of it actually. You can check it out here:
http://onetinyleap.wordpress.com/2012/0 ... ermission/

[Korban3]

Cool demo. Are you going to play with nav mesh pathfinding at all? That's really interesting stuff and allows agents to navigate without paths and is much preferable to waypoint grids.

[LeiterJakab]

I use Aron Granberg's A* project for pathfinding and graph creation. The demo actually uses a navmesh for pathfinding. It is an automatically created mesh, using a Recast implementation for Unity. Recast is the tool used in Overgrowth as well.

[Korban3]

Cool.
I asked because the paths they followed seemed rather waypointy. But awesome, I didn't know there was a Recast for Unity.

EDIT OUT ALL TEH TYPOS